M M Basheer chose to write on Valmiki's interpretation of Rama and landed in controversy. |
Staff correspondent, September 4, 2015, NewsCrunch
Malayalam Muslim critic M M Basheer aborted a six-column series on Ramayana, which he was writing for Matrubhumi.
The former professor of Calicut university said he was getting calls from people identifying themselves as Hindus and saying he did not have a right to write on Ramayana, reports The Indian Express.
Last year, Basheer had done another series dwelling on the godly-qualities of Rama and it had passed on without any incident. This year he chose to write on Valmiki's interpretation of Rama. Valmiki treats Rama as human and questions many of his actions such as subjecting Sita to agni pariksha.
People who called Basheer were reportedly upset that a Muslim was criticising Rama treating him as an ordinary man.
The controversy found its echo on Twitter where many agreed with the sentiments of the Hindu groups in opposing a Muslim scholar writing on Ramayana.
The conservative Hindu opinion also asked if Basheer would dare to write critically about Islam or Christianty.
Almost no one in this group went into the nuances of the issue and examined if Basheer had read Valmiki right.
However, there were also a few tweets in support of Basheer. One of them said India was not Saudi Arabia or Afghanistan to enforce that only Hindus could comment on Ramayana.
Twitter chatter on Malayalam critic Basheer's Ramayana controversy
@peter_vas Really sad that commie people of Kerala get taught about distorted Ramayana by a Mapilla writer— Vijay Pai (@paivijay) September 4, 2015
Did M.M Basheer ever criticized koran in its entirety? Criticizing #Ramayana#Geeta#Yoga#Veda is the routine jobs for Adash Liberals.— Priya Prativa Roy (@priyaprativa) September 4, 2015
If any one write about prophet then backlash is sure. #Ramayana— Priya Prativa Roy (@priyaprativa) September 4, 2015
@waglenikhil@unnishanker For you its not about Ramayana its all about being relevant with your idiotic logics #GoHomeJournosURDrunk— Mahesh Raghuwanshi (@Mahesh_aarvind) September 4, 2015
@waglenikhil@unnishanker replace Hindu with Muslim & vice-versa and Ramayana with Prophet. They'd have killed him then...— VeeGee Narendra (@VeGeEn) September 4, 2015
why it is (http://t.co/gywC7RFjxR) happening sir @PMOIndia. Hope you must act!— sujeet kumar (@sujeet84) September 4, 2015
Shocking! ''@unnishanker: Hindu group forces Muslim writer in Kerala to stop Ramayana column http://t.co/f9ZbHzv2XNpic.twitter.com/fjoRh9H2U2”— nikhil wagle (@waglenikhil) September 4, 2015
A bright future for my beloved nation. Am I residing in Saudi Arabia or Afghanistan? http://t.co/UvlfkOoCvM— Vijayakrishnan G (@gvijayakrishnan) September 4, 2015
Today in encroached freedoms: Hindu group forces Muslim writer in Kerala to stop Ramayana column http://t.co/Lkznd39WH5#India#literature— Sharanya Manivannan (@ranyamanivannan) September 4, 2015
“Mappilah Ramayanam” is a Muslim version of the Ramayana in Kerala. Sadly Muslim columnist asked to shut up https://t.co/vjqMHMqxVo— Peter Vas (@peter_vas) September 4, 2015